A Flawless Card Can Still Miss the 10: the 4 Subgrades That Cap Your Score
Centering, corners, edges and surface each set a ceiling on your grade. How each sub-grade caps the score, why 9.5 is the top in practice, and what that means for a PSA 10.
By the Gradeon Team · Updated
A card that looks flawless can still miss the top grade because each of its four sub-grades, centering, corners, edges and surface, sets a ceiling, and the overall grade can never be more than 1.0 above the weakest one.
Collectors often expect a clean-looking card to get a 10. Here is why that rarely happens, area by area.
1. Centering
Centering is the only area that can score a full 10 in Gradeon, and only when the card is within 2% of perfect (50/50 to 52/48 on both axes). A card at 58/42 scores 8 on centering, however clean the rest is, and the cap rule then holds that side to 9.
2. Corners
Corners top out at 9.5, because a 10 would need magnification a phone photo cannot give. A single dot of whitening on one corner caps corners at 9, and any softness caps them at 8.
3. Edges
Edges also top out at 9.5. One defect along the border, such as a speck of whitening or silvering, caps edges at 9.
4. Surface
Surface carries the most weight, 35% of each side's grade, and tops out at 9.5. One minor flaw, such as a faint print line, limits it to 9; a crease caps it at 6.
How the caps combine
Each side's grade is the weighted average of its four sub-grades, capped at the lowest sub-grade plus 1.0 and rounded to the nearest 0.5. The card's grade is the average of the front and back, capped at the weaker side plus 1.0.
Rule
Effect
No defect in an area
That area can reach 9.5
1 defect in an area
That area is capped at 9
2 defects in an area
Capped at 8
Any defect of severity 3+
Capped at 7
Weakest area
Side capped at weakest + 1.0
Weaker side
Card capped at weaker side + 1.0
In plain words: one visible defect costs you Gem Mint, two cost you Mint.
Why is 9.5 the top grade in practice?
Because corners, edges and surface stop at 9.5, the highest overall grade Gradeon awards today is 9.5 Gem Mint. A card with no defects found defaults to 9.0 on an area, not 9.5; a 9.5 needs the inspection to describe mint condition explicitly. A Gradeon 9.5 is the card you submit hoping for a PSA 10.
What about the back?
The back is graded exactly as strictly as the front. A perfect front with a 7 back gives an average of 8.25, capped at 8, rounded to 8. The back can pull a flawless front down by a full grade or more.
Because each sub-grade sets a ceiling. In Gradeon, corners, edges and surface top out at 9.5 from phone photos, one visible defect caps an area at 9, and the overall grade can never be more than 1.0 above the weakest area.
What is the highest grade Gradeon gives?
9.5 Gem Mint. Only centering can score a full 10, so 9.5 is the highest overall grade the app awards today.
Does the back of the card affect the grade?
Yes. The back gets its own four sub-grades, and the card's grade can never be more than 1.0 above the weaker side.