Article

Nov 17, 2026

PSA, BGS, CGC: 6 Differences That Change Which One You Should Use

Scale and labels, sub-grades, the top grade, fees, turnaround and crossover services: six differences between PSA, BGS and CGC, with fees from each company’s own price list.

By the Gradeon Team · Updated

Gradeon Journal cover for “PSA, BGS, CGC: 6 Differences That Change Which One You Should Use”

PSA, BGS and CGC differ in six ways that matter: how they show the grade, whether they publish sub-grades, what their top grade means, their fees, their turnaround and whether they will cross over a card from another company.

All three authenticate a card, grade it on a 1–10 scale and seal it in a slab. The differences decide which one suits a given card.

1. The scale and its labels

PSA is the reference for the 1–10 scale and its labels: Gem Mint 10, Mint 9, NM-MT 8 and so on down. Gradeon's scale and labels are PSA-comparable, which is why a Gradeon pre-grade maps to an estimated PSA tier.

2. Sub-grades

BGS (Beckett Grading Services) is known for its four sub-grades: centering, corners, edges and surface, the same four Gradeon uses. CGC Cards also publishes sub-grades and half points. If you want to see where a card lost points, a slab with sub-grades tells you more.

3. The top grade

BGS's highest grade is the Black Label: a 10 with all four sub-grades at 10. Each company has its own definition of the very top, so a "10" does not mean the same thing everywhere.

4. Fees

Fees are per card, in tiers set by the card's declared or insured value. From each company's US price list on 26 September 2026:

Company and tier

Fee per card (USD)

Max value per card (USD)

PSA Standard

$59.99

$1,000

PSA Priority

$79.99

$1,500

PSA Express

$199

$2,500

CGC Bulk (25-card minimum)

$17

$500

CGC Economy

$20

$1,000

CGC Standard

$55

$3,000

Sources: PSA, which notes its Value services are temporarily paused, and CGC Cards. Beckett's price page showed a maintenance notice for Beckett EU when we checked, so check Beckett's current list directly. Fees change and differ by region.

5. Turnaround

Company and tier

Estimated turnaround

PSA Standard

90–100 business days

PSA Priority

70–80 business days

PSA Express

20–30 business days

CGC Bulk

150 working days

CGC Economy

90 working days

CGC Standard

10 working days

Both companies state that turnaround times are estimates, not guarantees.

6. Crossover

A crossover moves a graded card from one company's slab to another's. CGC offers a CrossOver service for cards in PSA, Beckett or SGC holders: the card is re-slabbed only if CGC believes it will get the same or a higher grade, unless you ask to cross at any grade. That gives you a way to change companies later without cracking the slab yourself.

Which one should you use?

It depends on the card and your goal. If you sell into a market where PSA slabs are the reference, PSA's scale is the one buyers read. If you want sub-grades on the label, BGS or CGC show them. If cost per card matters most, compare the tiers that cover your card's value. Whatever you choose, check each company's pop report for your card.

Pre-grade before you pick

A Gradeon pre-grade estimates the grade PSA, BGS or CGC would most likely give your card, on a PSA-comparable scale. It is not an official grade, but it tells you whether a card is worth submitting at all.

Download Gradeon

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between PSA and BGS?

Both grade on a 1–10 scale. BGS is known for printing four sub-grades (centering, corners, edges, surface) and for its Black Label, a 10 with all four sub-grades at 10.

Which grading company is cheapest?

On the US price lists checked on 26 September 2026, CGC's Bulk tier was $17 per card (25-card minimum, cards up to $500), and PSA's lowest active tier was Standard at $59.99. Prices change, so check each company's current list.

Can I move a card from PSA to CGC?

Yes, through CGC's CrossOver service, which re-slabs a PSA, Beckett or SGC card if CGC believes it will get the same or a higher grade.

Visioned and Crafted by Daniele Dominici & Federico Vietti

© 2026 Gradeon AI. All rights reserved.

Visioned and Crafted by
Daniele Dominici & Federico Vietti

© 2026 Gradeon AI. All rights reserved.