Article

Oct 13, 2026

Your Card Is Damaged — 5 Checks Before You Write It Off

Crease or light bend? Deep whitening or a few specks? Scratch or print line? Five checks that tell you how bad the damage really is before you give up on a card.

By the Gradeon Team · Updated

Gradeon Journal cover for “Your Card Is Damaged — 5 Checks Before You Write It Off”

Before you write off a damaged card, check five things: whether it is a crease or a light bend, how deep the whitening goes, whether a line is a scratch or a print line, whether a mark is a dent, and whether it is just dirt.

Some damage is permanent and caps a grade hard. Some is cosmetic, or not damage at all. These five checks tell you which is which, using the same rules Gradeon applies when it pre-grades a card.

1. Is it a crease or just a light bend?

A crease is a fold line: you can see broken print or white fibres along it, or a corner that stays bent or lifted. It is the most expensive defect. In Gradeon, any crease caps the surface sub-grade at 6, and two creases, or one that runs beyond the border, cap it at 4.

A light, even bow with no fold line and no broken print is different. The app's restoration advice may flag it as restorable, because light pressing can sometimes flatten a slight bow. Pressing is legitimate only when it removes nothing and adds nothing.

2. How deep does the whitening go?

Whitening is the white core showing through where colour has worn off an edge or corner. A few specks on one corner are minor: in Gradeon, whitening on one corner caps corners at 9. Whitening on two or more corners caps them at 8.

The line to watch is where whitening becomes fraying, fibres lifting from the edge, or edge wear, where the border itself is ragged. Those cost more, and none of them can be repaired.

3. Is that line a scratch or a print line?

A scratch is cut into the surface, can be straight or curved, and on holo cards it breaks the rainbow pattern. A print line is perfectly straight, usually runs the full height or width of the card and comes from the printing press.

Both count against the grade, but a faint print line (severity 1–2) usually costs less than a scratch across the artwork (severity 3).

4. Is it a dent or a crease?

A dent is a pressure mark: a small depression or bump from a fingernail, a stacked object or a binder ring. It shows as a shadow or a shine distortion when you tilt the card, and it has no fold line. Most dents rate severity 1, far below a crease. If you can see a fold line, it is a crease.

5. Is it damage, or just dirt?

Dirt is something on the card rather than damage to it: a fingerprint, a smudge, residue or a stuck fibre. It usually rates severity 1, and it is the one issue that light cleaning can sometimes remove. Never rub hard: cleaning that removes ink or gloss turns dirt into real surface damage.

What damage is permanent?

Whitening, creases and chips are permanent. A card that has been altered to hide them, for example with inked edges or trimmed borders, is an altered card, and grading companies refuse to grade altered cards. Gradeon does not detect alterations, so check yourself before you submit.

Is a damaged card still worth anything?

Often yes. A creased card tops out around 7 overall in Gradeon, but a 7 on a valuable card can still be worth more than a clean common. Check its raw value before deciding, and see the 11 defects every grader looks for for the full list.

See exactly what the damage costs

Run a Full Grade and Gradeon marks every defect on your photo, rates it from 1 to 5 and tells you whether light cleaning or pressing could help.

Download Gradeon

Frequently asked questions

Can a creased card still be graded?

Yes, grading companies grade creased cards, but a crease caps the grade hard. In Gradeon, any crease caps the surface sub-grade at 6, so a creased card tops out around 7 overall.

Can I fix whitening on a card?

No. Whitening is missing colour on the edge or corner layer and is permanent. Covering it with ink makes the card an altered card, which grading companies refuse to grade.

How do I tell a dent from a crease?

Tilt the card under a light. A dent shows as a shadow or shine distortion with no fold line. A crease has a fold line with broken print or white fibres.

Visioned and Crafted by Daniele Dominici & Federico Vietti

© 2026 Gradeon AI. All rights reserved.

Visioned and Crafted by
Daniele Dominici & Federico Vietti

© 2026 Gradeon AI. All rights reserved.